The dense coat of glycosylphosphatidylinositol (GPI)-anchored variant surface glycoprotein (VSG) covering parasitic African trypanosomes is essential for survival in mammalian hosts. VSG is internalised and recycled exclusively via a specialised part of the plasma membrane, the flagellar pocket. Direct measurement of the kinetics of VSG endocytosis and recycling shows that the VSG cell-surface pool is turned over within 12 minutes. Correspondingly, the turnover of the intracellular pool (9±4% of total VSG) requires only 1 minute, and this is an exceptionally high rate considering that endocytosis and exocytosis are limited to only 5% of the cell surface area. Kinetic 3D co-localisation analysis using biotinylated VSG and a panel of compartmental markers provides consistent evidence for the itinerary of VSG through the cell: VSG is endocytosed in large clathrin-coated vesicles, which bud from the flagellar pocket membrane at a rate of 6-7 vesicles per second, and is then delivered to RAB5-positive early endosomes. From there, VSG is recycled to RAB11-positive recycling endosomes at two stages, either directly or via RAB7-positive, late endosomes. Small clathrin-coated vesicles carrying fluid-phase cargo and being depleted of VSG bud from early and recycling endosomes. These vesicles are postulated to deliver their content to late endosomes and/or the lysosome. The recycling endosomes give rise to RAB11-positive exocytic carriers that fuse with the flagellar pocket and thereby return VSG to the cell surface. VSG recycling provides an interesting model for studies on the cellular trafficking and sorting of GPI-anchored proteins.
Unravelling the mechanisms of endocytosis, as well as of the ensuing intracellular sorting and recycling processes, is of central importance for understanding the communication of eukaryotic cells with their environment (Mellman, 1996; Mukherjee et al., 1997; Gruenberg, 2001). For the mammalian stage of the unicellular flagellate, Trypanosoma brucei, which is the causative agent of sleeping sickness in man and for nagana in cattle, this environment is the mammalian vascular system that provides all the required high and low molecular weight nutrients. For several reasons, T. brucei provides an interesting system for studies on endo- and exocytosis, particularly in relation to the trafficking and sorting of glycosylphosphatidylinositol (GPI)-anchored proteins: First, this parasite restricts both endocytosis and exocytosis to the flagellar pocket that consists of an invagination of the plasma membrane around the emerging flagellum and comprises an area of only approximately 5% of the cell surface. Second, all endosomal membrane structures are compactly organised in the posterior half of the cell between the flagellar pocket and the nucleus. Third, each cell expresses 107 molecules of a predominant surface protein, the GPI-anchored variant surface glycoprotein (VSG) (Webster and Russel, 1993; Overath et al., 1997; Landfear and Ignatushchenko, 2001; Morgan et al., 2002a; Morgan et al., 2002b).
T. brucei supports fluid-phase endocytosis, which can deliver markers such as ferritin or complexes of various proteins and colloidal gold from the flagellar pocket to tubulocisternal endosomes and then to the perinuclear lysosome (Langreth and Balber, 1975; Webster and Grab, 1988; Frevert and Reinwald, 1988; Webster, 1989), as well as receptor-mediated endocytosis of growth factors such as transferrin and LDL (Coppens et al., 1987). VSG is conveyed to endosomes by coated vesicles and indirect evidence suggests that it is efficiently recycled (Webster and Grab, 1988; Frevert and Reinwald, 1988; Seyfang et al., 1990; Grünfelder et al., 2003). Moreover, T. brucei clears anti-VSG antibodies from the cell surface (Russo et al., 1993; O'Beirne et al., 1998), and this process, in addition to the well-known antigenic variation, may contribute to parasite persistence in the immuno-competent host.
The recent identification of clathrin and several marker proteins for endosomal sub-compartments in T. brucei (Field et al., 1998; Morgan et al., 2001; Jeffries et al., 2001; Pal et al., 2002; Alexander et al., 2002) has provided a basis for a more detailed analysis of endocytosis and the intracellular trafficking of VSG. In the first part of this study, we quantify the rates of VSG endocytosis and recycling. In the second part, we propose an intracellular itinerary for the VSG through the endosomal compartment. We argue that this parasite has optimised endocytosis and recycling of GPI-anchored proteins as an adaptation to its unique lifestyle and therefore provides an interesting model for further analysis of this pathway.
Materials and Methods
Trypanosomes and cell culture
T. brucei MITat 1.2 expresses the wild-type (WT) VSG 221 (N-terminus of the mature protein: NH2-AAEKGFKQAFWQPLC-) from the 221 expression site. In strain MITat 1.2-Ty-1 a vsg 221-gene encoding a Ty-1 tag (NH2-AAEKGAREVHTNQDPLDKQAFWQPLC-; tag in bold letters, amino acid changes because of cloning in italics) has been inserted into the 221 expression site, whereas the WT vsg 221 gene has been deleted. Therefore, this strain synthesises the tagged VSG at WT expression levels (M.E., unpublished). The cells were grown as described before (Grünfelder et al., 2002). For MITat1.2-Ty-1, the medium contained 15 μg/ml Geneticin and 10 μg/ml Blasticidin S (ICN, Eschwege, Germany).
The peptide NH2-AAEKGFKQAFWQPLC-COOH corresponding to the NH2-terminus of VSG-221 from clone MITat 1.2 was coupled to ovalbumin via the cross-linker SPDP (Pierce, Rockford, IL) and the resulting conjugate was used to immunise rabbits or mice (nanotools Antikörpertechnik, Teningen, Germany). The resulting high-titered anti-N-terminal peptide antisera (anti-VSG-NTP) from one rabbit (H1) or one C57BL6-mouse (3-18III) was used in the VSG recycling experiments. Both antisera reacted with live MITat 1.2-Ty-1 cells but not with cells expressing WT VSG 221. Approximately 90% of the mouse serum reactivity could be abolished by acetylation of live MITat 1.2-Ty-1 cells using sulfo-NHS-acetate (Pierce). This observation provided the basis for measuring the rate of VSG recycling (see below).
Endocytosis of surface biotinylated proteins
Cultures of exponentially growing MITat 1.2 cells (5-8×105/ml) were divided in 50 ml tubes, chilled on ice for 10 minutes and centrifuged for 15 minutes at 750 g (1500 rpm) in a Heraeus-Christ Minifuge GL in the cold. Cells were washed twice in trypanosome dilution buffer (TDB, 5 mM KCl, 80 mM NaCl, 1 mM MgSO4, 20 mM Na2HPO4, 2 mM NaH2PO4, 20 mM glucose, pH 7.4), and then biotinylated strictly at 0°C and at a density of 1×108 cells/ml (total volume 2 ml) with 1 mM sulfo-NHS-SS-biotin (Pierce) for 10 minutes. After addition of 1 M Tris-Cl, pH 7.5, to a final concentration of 10 mM, the cells were centrifuged and taken up in 300 μl TDB. Duplicate aliquots (10 μl) were processed as follows: first, fixation in 250 μl 4% formaldehyde in 0.2 M HEPES, pH 7.4; second, addition at 0°C to a mixture of 90 μl HMI-9+iFCS and 1 ml stripping solution (18 ml RPMI medium, 9 ml water, 3 ml iFCS and 465 mg glutathione, adjusted to pH 8.5 at room temperature, then chilled on ice); third, the cells were added to 90 μl HMI-9+iFCS prewarmed to 37°C, incubated from 10 seconds to 30 minutes and then diluted with 1 ml ice-cold stripping solution. Stripping was performed for 30 minutes on ice. The cells were then collected by centrifugation (2 minutes at 8000 rpm/6000 g in an Eppendorf centrifuge), suspended in 10 μl TDB and fixed for 1 hour at 0°C in formaldehyde/HEPES. After washing in 500 μl PBS, the cells were resuspended in 50 μl PBS and permeabilised for 5 minutes at –20°C with 200 μl methanol previously cooled to this temperature. After centrifugation, the cells were processed as follows: incubation for 30 minutes in blocking solution (2% BSA/PBS/20 mM Tris-Cl/0.1% saponin, pH 7.0), addition of 200 μl Strepavidin Alexa Fluor® 488 (5 μg/ml obtained from Molecular Probes, Eugene, OR) in blocking solution, 1-hour incubation, washed once in 200 μl blocking solution, washed once in 200 μl PBS, resuspension in 0.5 ml PBS and FACS analysis (Fig. 1A).
Alternatively, the stripped cells were resuspended in 200 μl HMI-9-iFCS and fixed overnight by the addition of 300 μl 4% formaldehyde in HEPES. The cells were then washed once in 500 μl PBS, once in 500 μl PBS/2% BSA, incubated for 15 minutes in 500 μl 0.1 M Na2HPO4/0.1 M glycine, pH 7.2 and then permeabilised for 5 minutes by the addition of 500 μl 0.2% Triton-X-100 in PBS. After centrifugation, the cells were taken up in PBS/BSA and stained with Streptavidin Alexa Fluor as described above. As judged by cytofluorimetric analysis, the two permeabilisation protocols gave the same results. However, the second procedure was superior regarding the preservation of cell morphology.
For microscopic demonstration of VSGbiotin uptake (Fig. 2A), 20 μl of biotinylated cells (4×108/ml) were added to 180 μl of HMI-9+iFCS (37°C) and endocytosis was allowed for 0-120 seconds. The reaction was stopped by the addition of 1.8 ml of ice-cold stripping buffer (60% HMI-9, 10% iFCS, 50 mM glutathione, pH 9.0). Cells were fixed with 4% paraformaldehyde in PBS for 24 hours at 4°C and permeabilised with Triton X100 as described above. VSGbiotin was detected with Alexa Fluor 488 conjugated Streptavidin (10 μg/ml). For immunodetection of the lysosomal marker p67, the monoclonal antibody mAb280 (1:1000 in PBS/1% BSA; courtesy of Jay Bangs, Madison, WI) and CY3-conjugated goat anti-mouse antibody (1:2000) were used.
For co-localisation of VSGbiotin with endosomal markers (Fig. 3A-D), cells were incubated for 10 minutes on ice in the dark with 1 mM sulfo-NHS-SS-biotin and 1 mM AMCA-sulfo-NHS (Pierce). Endocytosis and processing for immunofluorescence were performed as described above. For each time point, aliquots of the same batch of fixed and permeabilised cells were incubated with four different antibodies. For immunodetection of RAB5A, RAB11 or clathrin heavy chain, polyclonal rabbit antisera (1:200 in PBS/1% BSA; kind gifts of Mark C. Field, Imperial College London, UK) and Alexa Fluor 488 conjugated goat anti-rabbit antibody (1:2000; Molecular Probes) were used. RAB7 was detected with a polyclonal rat antibody diluted 1:50 (M.E. and M.B., unpublished) and Cy2-conjugated goat anti-rat IgG. For detection of VSGbiotin, Alexa Fluor 594 conjugated Streptavidin (10 μg/ml; Molecular Probes) was added, together with the secondary reagent.
Recycling of VSG
MITat 221-Ty-1 cells were harvested, washed and suspended at 0°C in TDB (500 μl at 5×108 cells/ml). Duplicate aliquots (20 μl) were either diluted with cold 200 μl HMI-9+iFCS or with 200 μl HMI-9+iFCS containing 0.5% mouse anti-VSG-NTP serum. The rest of the cells (400 μl) were mixed with 1.6 ml TDB containing 5 mM sulfo-NHS-acetate (added immediately before the cells from a freshly prepared 1 M stock solution in dimethylsulfoxide), kept for 5 minutes, treated with 20 μl 1 M Tris-Cl, pH 7.4, washed once with TDB and taken up in 400 μl TDB (all operations strictly at 0°C). Aliquots (20 μl) were either diluted with cold antibody solution or first transferred to warm Eppendorf tubes (38°C), incubated for various times and then diluted with 200 μl cold antibody solution. The cells were incubated for 30 minutes on ice, washed twice with 500 μl TDB, suspended in 10 μl TDB and fixed with 200 μl 4% formaldehyde/0.1% glutaraldehyde in 0.2 M HEPES, pH 7.4, overnight. The cells were then processed for immunofluorescence and FACS analysis using FITC-labelled goat anti-mouse F(ab′)2 fragments (1:100, Dianova, Hamburg, Germany). In some experiments, the mouse anti-VSG-NTP antibodies were replaced by rabbit anti-VSG-NTP serum (dilution 1:100) and Alexa-Fluor 488 goat anti-rabbit IgG (1:100, Molecular Probes). The results are shown in Fig. 1B.
For microscopic demonstration of recycling (Fig. 2B), cells that had taken up VSGbiotin to the steady state (3 minutes) were stripped for 5 minutes on ice with glutathione solution (pH 9.0). Aliquots of 2×107 cells were then added to 180 μl of pre-warmed HMI-9+iFCS, and exocytosis was allowed for 0 seconds to 5 minutes. The reaction was stopped by the addition of 1.8 ml ice-cold 4% paraformaldehyde in PBS, and immunofluorescence was performed as described.
Kinetics of fluid-phase endocytosis
Freshly harvested MITat 1.2 trypanosomes were taken up in HMI-9+iFCS at a density of 4×108 cells/ml and kept on ice. Duplicate samples of pre-warmed HMI-9+iFCS (45 μl), containing 0.25, 0.125 or 0.0625 mg Alexa Fluor 488 dextran conjugate (Molecular Probes, Cat. No. D-22910) and 2×106 cells (5 μl), were incubated for the indicated times at 37°C, diluted with 1 ml cold HMI-9+iFCS and centrifuged. The cells were washed once with 1 ml cold TDB, fixed with 4% formaldehyde/0.1% glutaraldehyde in 0.2 M HEPES, pH 7.4 for 1 hour on ice and transferred to PBS for FACS analysis. In controls, aliquots of fluorescent dextran were diluted with HMI-9 before addition of the cells. The dextran endocytosis was standardised as follows: the absorbance of a Streptavidin Alexa Fluor 488 conjugate solution (25 μg in 1 ml PBS) was determined at 493 nm. The solution was rotated overnight in the cold room with 50 μl biotin-labelled microspheres (Molecular Probes). Measurement of the absorbance of the supernatant after pelleting the beads and the bead count allowed the determination of the amount of fluorochrome bound per bead. The beads were stored in the presence of the supernatant; before use, an aliquot was centrifuged and washed twice in PBS. Fluid-phase uptake was quantified by comparing the fluorescence of the beads with that of the cells by way of cytofluorimetric analysis (Fig. 1C).
Modelling of VSG internalisation and recycling, and of fluid-phase endocytosis
where A=ne/(ns+ne) (%), K=k×(1/ns+1/ne) (1/s), Kd=kd/(2×ne) (1/s), kb=0 (because biosynthetic VSG is not biotinylated), and L=lag after cooling (seconds).
where the symbols have the same meaning as above, Kb=kb/(2×ne) and kd=0 because degradation of acetylated VSG does not affect the signal. All fittings were performed using the Prism 3 software (Graphpad, San Diego, CA).
where n=(ne+nLy) (mole cell-1) corresponds to the sum of marker in endosomes and lysosomes, ve (μm3 cell-1) is the volume of the endosome compartment, c is the extracellular concentration of the fluid-phase marker, and λ=(ko+k)/ve.
Image acquisition, deconvolution and quantitative co-localisation analysis
Three-dimensional image acquisition, digital deconvolution and image analysis was performed as described (Grünfelder et al., 2003). Briefly, a motorized Zeiss Axiophot2 widefield microscope, a PIFOC objective z-stepper and either the Princeton Instruments `Micromax' cooled slow-scan CCD camera (KAF-1400 chip) or the CoolSnap HQ cooled CCD camera (Sony ICX285 chip) were used for image acquisition. Following deconvolution with the Huygens Professional software (Scientific Volume Imaging, Hilversum, The Netherlands), the restored image dataset was analysed using the Imaris Surpass software package (Bitplane, Zurich, Switzerland). Co-localisation analysis of deconvolved 3D-images was performed with the colocalisation software (version 1.0, Bitplane). Throughout the experiments, the selection of cells for analysis was done `blindly' without knowing the identity of the sample. Furthermore, the identification of representative cells was performed by applying customised software scripts (based on IPLab, Scanalytics, Fairfax, VA) that segment, classify and rank all objects (cells) within an image, resulting in a colour-coded overlay. This ensured that only cells that revealed the predominant phenotype were analysed.
Kinetics of endocytosis and recycling of VSG
Trypanosomes expressing VSG 221 (variant clone MITat 1.2) were surface biotinylated by using the impermeable reagent sulfo-succinimidyl-2-(biotinamido)-ethyl-1,3-dithiopropionate (sulfo-NHS-SS-biotin). Under our labelling conditions, >95% of all biotin label is associated with VSG (VSGbiotin) (Grünfelder et al., 2002). The cells were incubated for various times at 37°C to allow endocytosis to proceed and then the surface-associated biotin was stripped by an excess of glutathione at 0°C and pH 8.5. The cells were fixed, permeabilised, labelled with fluorescent Streptavidin and analysed by flow cytometry. The time course of endocytosis for VSGbiotin from the cell surface to endosomal membranes is shown in Fig. 1A. After a short lag (16 seconds), the cells rapidly internalised VSGbiotin, leading to a steady-state after approximately 2 minutes. Thereafter, a slow decrease was observed, possibly because of the removal of biotin label by disulfide reduction in late endosomes (Fivaz et al., 2002). The curve describes the best fit of a two-step kinetic model, consisting of the reversible flow of VSG between the surface and the endocytic compartment, and an endosomal degradation step that leads to a loss of the signal (see Eqn 1). Values for the following parameters could be obtained from this simulation: (1) At steady state, 8.9±0.6% of the total VSGbiotin was located in the endosomal compartment, with the complementary fraction of 91.1% being on the cell surface. (2) VSG exchange between the cell surface and an intracellular pool could be described by a bi-directional rate constant of 0.145±0.04 surface equivalents of VSG per minute; thus, one surface equivalent was internalised every 7±1.8 minutes, or one VSG equivalent of the endosomal compartment was recycled every 0.7 minutes. (3) Biotin label was lost from the cells with a half-life of 3.6±1.1 hours.
Recycling of VSGbiotin after endocytosis could be demonstrated during a second incubation of the stripped cells at 37°C by fluorescence microscopy (see below). However, we were unable to obtain reproducible quantitative data using this technique, most probably because of the stressful stripping conditions. Therefore, we resorted to the following procedure: Strain MITat 221-Ty-1 expresses a mutant vsg 221 gene, with the yeast Ty-1 epitope tag inserted close to the N-terminus (NH2-AAEKGAREVHTNQDPLDKQAFWQPLC-; tag in bold letters, amino acid changes because of cloning in italics), whereas the WT vsg 221 gene has been deleted (M.E., unpublished). This modified VSG was recognised by antipeptide antibodies to the N-terminus of VSG 221 on live trypanosomes and, moreover, most of this reaction could be abolished by treating the cells with the membrane-impermeable acetylation reagent N-hydroxysulfosuccinimide acetate (sulfo-NHS-acetate). Therefore, MITat 221-Ty-1 cells were acetylated at 0°C, then incubated at 37°C for different times, fixed, labelled using the anti-peptide and secondary antibodies and then subjected to flow cytometric analysis. The time course for the redistribution of the non-acetylated VSG from endosomes to the cell surface is shown in Fig. 1B. Simulation of the data with the same two-step model as described above (but taking the biosynthesis of VSG into account) (see Eqn 2) yielded values for the following parameters: (1) The relative pool size of VSG in endosomes was 9.1±3.2% of the total cell-associated VSG. (2) Bi-directional exchange occurred with a rate constant of 0.056±0.034 surface equivalents per minute; thus, one surface equivalent of VSG was recycled every 18±11 minutes, or one VSG equivalent of the endosomal compartment was recycled every 1.8 minutes. (3) The biosynthesis of VSG contributed to the non-acetylated VSG pool and led to an increase in signal that doubled with a half time, t1/2=21±32 hours.
Kinetics of fluid-phase endocytosis
The time course of fluid-phase uptake of Alexa 488 dextran conjugate by trypanosomes is shown in Fig. 1C. Uptake was linearly dependent on the dextran concentration (data not shown). After normalising uptake values to the same dextran concentration, the averaged results could be simulated by a two-step model, comprising a reversible uptake step into endosomes as characterised by forward and backward rate constants, ki and ko, respectively, and a rate constant k=ki–ko for the transfer of the dextran from endosomes to the lysosome (see Eqn 3). These kinetics describe fluid uptake at a rate ki=0.19±0.03 μm3 (cell minute)-1 and the release of marker at a rate ko=0.17±0.026 μm3 (cell minute)-1. Therefore, the net uptake occurred at a rate k=0.02±0.002 μm3 (cell minute)-1; i.e. only approximately 10% of the pinocytosed marker was retained by the cells (see change in slope in the uptake curve in Fig. 1C). The marker filled an endosomal volume, ve=0.69±0.08 μm3 cell-1 with a turnover time of τ=ve/ki=3.6 minutes. It should be noted that previous estimates for the rate of endocytosis by Fairlamb and Bowman (Fairlamb and Bowman, 1980) [0.01 μm3 (cell minute)-1 at 25°C] and Coppens et al. (Coppens et al., 1987) [0.017 μm3 (cell minute)-1 at 30°C] can now be assigned to the net rather than the 10 times faster initial rate of uptake.
The itinerary of VSG through the endosomal system
The flow of VSGbiotin through the endosomal system was studied by 3D deconvolution fluorescence microscopy and is presented in two ways. First, the different stages of endocytosis, recycling and the separation of VSGbiotin from dextran as fluid-phase marker are shown for representative cell images in Fig. 2A-C. Second, a time-resolved, quantitative co-localisation analysis is presented in Fig. 3, which was performed as follows: the cellular space occupied by a given marker was expressed as an ensemble of volume units (voxels of 41×41×50 nm3) and was measured after having defined a threshold for the detection of VSGbiotin above background fluorescence (signal strength, in general, at least 50 times above background). With the help of automated, stringent image segmentation and classification techniques it was ensured that the sampled cells were representative and comparable for a given population based on three criteria: (1) Only non-dividing cells were analysed, (2) the summed fluorescence intensity of all three image channels was equal, and (3) sampled cells were comparable in terms of the overall size of the compartment analysed. The graphs in Fig. 3A-D describe the kinetics of appearance and subsequent spreading of internalised VSGbiotin in a given marker-defined compartment. It has to be pointed out, that these data do not quantify the amount of VSGbiotin within a compartment and, therefore, they do not provide information on the flux of VSGbiotin, i.e. major and minor routes cannot be distinguished. Specific antibodies against clathrin (Morgan et al., 2001; Grünfelder et al., 2003) and three small GTPases (1) RAB5A, a marker for early endosomes (Pal et al., 2002; Chavrier et al., 1990), (2) RAB7, a marker for late endosomes (M.B., unpublished) (Chavrier et al., 1990), and (3) RAB11, a marker for recycling endosomes (Jeffries et al., 2001; Grünfelder et al., 2003) were used in this analysis.
Comparison of a cell biotinylated at 0°C (control) and a cell subsequently treated with glutathione at 0°C (0 seconds) confirmed that surface biotin was completely removed, also from the flagellar pocket membrane (Fig. 2A). Internalised VSGbiotin was detectable at the flagellar pocket only 2 seconds after initiation of endocytosis. Interestingly, VSGbiotin was then routed straight towards the lysosomal area, which was reached within 6-10 seconds. Co-localisation analysis with the lysosomal marker p67 demonstrated that VSGbiotin did not enter the lysosome, but was redirected back towards the flagellar pocket. After 40-50 seconds, a steady state in the spatial distribution of VSGbiotin between flagellar pocket and lysosome was reached.
After a short lag, which may be attributed to the recovery of the cells from cooling, VSGbiotin became rapidly (T1/2=2.2 seconds) associated with clathrin-containing structures (Fig. 3A). The kinetics of spreading into the clathrin-containing space was compatible with a first-order process. At steady state, which was reached after approximately 15 seconds, VSGbiotin co-localised with 65% of the cell-associated clathrin. We propose that the remaining 35% of the clathrin-containing space consisted mainly of VSG-free class II clathrin-coated vesicles that budded from endosomes (Grünfelder et al., 2003). By 2.2 seconds after entry into the clathrin compartment, VSGbiotin started to co-localise with RAB5A, the marker for early endosomes. This compartment was filled with a T1/2=5.7 seconds to 85%, suggesting that VSGbiotin traversed almost all of the RAB5A-positive space (Fig. 3B). After a further delay of approximately 2 seconds, VSGbiotin became detectable in late endosomes as indicated by its co-localisation with RAB7 (T1/2=3.8 seconds) (Fig. 3C), and, at steady state, occupied only 58% of this compartmental space. This indicated that a substantial fraction of the RAB7-positive space did not lie on the intracellular route of VSG and probably represented a later stage of late endosomes at which segregation between VSGbiotin and the fluid-phase cargo may have occurred already. Finally, at approximately 6 seconds after the onset of uptake (i.e. a lag of 11.1 seconds) (compare Fig. 3A with Fig. 3D), VSGbiotin entered RAB11-containing structures with biphasic kinetics: the first phase occurred with a T1/2=4.6±2 seconds, a time course similar to that found for VSGbiotin entering the RAB7-positive space. Although this process filled 53% of this space at steady state, the remaining 47% became populated with a T1/2=47±50 seconds, presumably representing a second and later stage for the production of VSG-containing recycling endosomes.
The uptake of fluorescently labelled dextran was followed in cells that were dually labelled at the surface with cleavable biotin and non-cleavable sulfo-succinimidyl-7-amino-4-methylcoumarin-3-acetic acid (AMCA-sulfo-NHS) (Fig. 2C). After stripping, the biotin signal was specific for endocytosed VSGbiotin. Although VSGAMCA was also endocytosed (Grünfelder et al., 2003), its fluorescence was quenched in endosomes and this label was therefore specific for surface-exposed VSGAMCA. Dextran was endocytosed together with VSGbiotin (yellow regions in Fig. 2C), however, thereafter it gradually segregated from internalised VSGbiotin, and reached a maximum of spatial separation after approximately 1 minute. Co-localisation with the lysosomal marker p67 revealed that dextran accumulated within the lysosome (data not shown). A quantitative analysis of the segregation of VSGbiotin and dextran is shown in Fig. 3E. The data suggest that at steady state 37% of the intracellular VSGbiotin did not lie on the endocytic route of internalised dextran. Of this 37%, 26±4% segregated from dextran with a T1/2=4.6 seconds (broken line), whereas the remaining 11±4% segregated with a T1/2=50 seconds. Because the lag (11.1 seconds) as well as both half times of VSG/dextran segregation were compatible with the time course of filling of the RAB11 compartment, we suggest that the separation of VSG from the fluid-phase marker occurred concurrently with the biphasic filling of the RAB11 space.
In an additional experiment, the exocytosis of VSGbiotin from the endosomal compartment was studied (Fig. 2B). VSGbiotin filled the flagellar pocket within 10-25 seconds, and after 30 seconds appeared on the pellicular cell surface. This was confirmed by specifically measuring cell surface VSGbiotin in non-permeabilised cells (data not shown). Within 2 minutes of exocytosis, the endocyctic compartment was emptied, and by 5 minutes biotinylated VSG was distributed over the cell surface.
Defining endosomal compartments
Fig. 4D summarises our present view of endosomal structures in T. brucei as deduced from recent microscopic and immunoelectron microscopic studies (Morgan et al., 2001; Jeffries et al., 2001; Grünfelder et al., 2003), as well as on new assignments in the present study that are based on the reactivity of antibodies against RAB5A and RAB7.
The ultrastructural evidence (see Grünfelder et al., 2003) and the phenotype of a conditional mutant where clathrin or epsin was downregulated by RNA-interference (M. Günzel and M.E., unpublished) strongly suggest that endocytosis occurs exclusively by way of class I clathrin-coated vesicles (CCVs, 135 nm in diameter) (Grünfelder et al., 2003), which bud from the flagellar pocket membrane.
In immunofluorescence, antibodies against RAB5A reacted with structures close to the lysosome (Fig. 4A). By evaluating 250 random cryosections in the electron microscope, 74% of the RAB5A-immuno gold label was associated with cisternal and vesicular profiles close to the lysosome, whereas the rest was associated with structures between the flagellar pocket and the nucleus. At least half of the labelled cisternae had circular profiles (cEC) (Fig. 4E). The cECs showed class II clathrin-coated budding structures. No RAB5A was detectable on the flagellar pocket membrane, the cell surface, extended cisternae (EC) corresponding to RAB11-positive recycling endosomes (Fig. 4E) and the RAB11-positive exocytic carrier vesicles (EXCs) (Fig. 4E). The circular endosomal profiles identified here as early endosomes resembled those observed in mammalian cells (Griffiths et al., 1989).
In immunofluorescence, antibodies against RAB7 labelled structures near the lysosome (Fig. 4B) in an area that was closely juxtaposed but distinct from the RAB5A-reactive area (Fig. 4C). On cryosections, these antibodies reacted specifically, but weakly with membrane structures adjacent to the lysosome. Occasionally, strongly positive, irregularly shaped, complex membrane structures (0.5-1 μm diameter) were observed (Fig. 4F) that resembled late endosomes in mammalian cells (Griffiths et al., 1989). Extended cisternae were negative for RAB7.
As shown before (Grünfelder et al., 2003), RAB11-positive EC and EXCs were found throughout the posterior half of the cell. We have suggested that these cisternae disintegrate into EXCs, which then fuse with the flagellar pocket membrane.
The ultrastructure of endosomes of T. brucei labelled by ferritin or horseradish peroxidase (HRP) as fluid-phase markers has been described in detail (Langreth and Balber, 1975; Webster, 1989). The definition of endosomal sub-compartment justified an extension of those studies (Fig. 4G-I). As expected, class I CCVs were labelled by both markers (see for HRP in Fig. 4G). Remarkably, ferritin (size 11 nm) was excluded from the narrow parts of circular cisternal profiles (cEC), EC (Fig. 4I) and EXCs. The exclusion of ferritin or transferrin-gold complexes from narrow cisternal structures has previously been observed by Langreth and Balber (Langreth and Balber, 1975) and Webster and Grab (Webster and Grab, 1988). Likewise, LDL particles are excluded from narrow cisternal or tubular endosomal structures in mammalian cells (Ghosh et al., 1994). In contrast, all of these structures were positive for the much smaller protein HRP (44 kDa) (Fig. 4G,H). The fact that HRP was present in EXCs suggested that this fluid-phase marker was recycled to the flagellar pocket. Importantly, incipient or free class II CCVs were strongly labelled by either HRP or ferritin (Fig. 4G-I). Because these vesicles budded from circular and extended cisternal profiles and, eventually, both ferritin and HPR ended up in the lysosome, we suggest that class II CCVs carry fluid-phase markers to late endosomes or to the lysosome or both.
Rates of VSG and fluid-phase endocytosis
The results for both the internalisation and the recycling of VSG in trypanosomes are compatible with a kinetic model for the overall homeostatic VSG exchange between the cell surface and an endosomal membrane pool. At steady state, the intracellular pool of VSG amounts to 9±4% of the total cell-associated VSG. This result is in reasonable agreement with previous estimates obtained by fluorescence (4.9%) or by immunoelectron microscopy (6.2%) (Grünfelder et al., 2002). The averaged rate of internalisation and recycling of VSG amounts to 8±4% VSG surface-equivalents per minute, implying that the entire surface pool is internalised and recycled once in approximately 12.5 minutes (Table 1). Because the intracellular VSG pool is approximately ten-times smaller, its turnover requires only approximately 1 minute.
|Cell type .||T. brucei .||Peritoneal macrophage* .||Baby hamster kidney cell† .||Fibroblast L-cell* .|
|Cell type .||T. brucei .||Peritoneal macrophage* .||Baby hamster kidney cell† .||Fibroblast L-cell* .|
Based on VSG data on the assumption that plasma membrane is internalised without a change in surface concentration of VSG, i.e. VSG is representative of total plasma membrane during internalisation. This is not true of endosomal membranes, but the internalisation rate of 0.19 μm2/s can be divided into the sterologically determined endosomal membrane area (>28.3 μm2) (Grünfelder et al., 2002) to calculate the turnover time for the endosome membrane pool.
Based on the rate of VSGbiotin internalisation
Based on the VSG recycling rate
Based on the rate of fluid phase uptake and the sterologically determined endosome volume (∼1 μm3 cell-1) (Grünfelder et al., 2002)
Based on the rate of fluid phase uptake and the measured endosome volume (0.69±0.08 μm3 cell-1)
A trypanosome takes up fluid at a rate of 0.19±0.03 μm3 (cell minute)-1 (Fig. 1C) into an endosome volume of 0.69±0.08 μm3 cell-1. This implies that the entire endosome volume is filled once approximately every 3.6 minutes. Because the lumen of endocytic vesicles (without the VSG coat) is approximately 0.1 μm in diameter, a volume of 0.69 μm3 corresponds to approximately 1350 vesicles with a combined surface area of approximately 42 μm2. Therefore, membrane is internalised at a rate of 42/3.6=11.7 μm2/minute. The estimate for the volume of the endosomal compartment is in reasonable agreement with stereologically determined, lower estimates of approximately 1 μm3 (Grünfelder et al., 2002). It is reassuring that the internalisation rate of 11.7 μm2/minute, which is based on surface to volume considerations, agrees with an averaged value of 11.5 μm2/minute obtained by relating the internalisation rate of VSG (8%/minute) to the surface area of 144 μm2 (Grünfelder et al., 2002). Therefore, internalisation of VSG is representative for the rate of membrane internalisation. This is in agreement with our previous observation that endocytosis of VSG in class I clathrin-coated vesicles occurs without a change in lateral concentration compared with the flagellar pocket membrane (Grünfelder et al., 2003). In contrast, a comparison between the time it takes to turn over one area equivalent of endosome membrane of >28.3 μm2 (Grünfelder et al., 2002) by a membrane flux of 11.7 μm2/minute, namely >2.4 minutes, and the time it takes to turn over one VSG equivalent of this compartment (approximately 1 minute, see above), implies that the VSG density is >2.4-fold less in endosomes than on the cell surface. In rough agreement with this estimate, we previously concluded using immuno-gold electron microscopy that, on average, the VSG density in endosomes is 4.8-fold less than on the plasma/flagellar pocket membrane (Grünfelder et al., 2002).
The rate of endosome volume turnover in T. brucei is 1.5 to 3.1 times faster than in macrophages or fibroblasts. T. brucei turns over its cell surface 2.6 times faster than macrophages and 5-9 times faster than fibroblasts (as an average from several studies) (for a review, see Thilo, 1985) (see Table 1 for direct comparison with data from two specific studies). This rate turns out to be exceptionally high when it is considered that membrane internalisation occurs only from a specialised surface domain, the flagellar pocket, that is, one surface area equivalent is internalised through only 1/20th of this area in 12.5 minutes. Because endocytosis appears to occur exclusively via clathrin-coated vesicles, this implies that 6-7 class I CCVs (4% of the total pocket area) are internalised every second. Qualitatively, this result is consistent with the abundance of these vesicles within the cell as identified in electron microscopic sections of trypanosomes after short incubation times with HRP. However, at steady state only two clathrin-coated pits per flagellar pocket are present (C.G.G., unpublished), suggesting that their life time is significantly shorter than in mammalian cells (20-80 seconds) (Gaidorov et al., 1999). The restriction of endocytosis to the flagellar pocket membrane of T. brucei is reminiscent of the recently described, specialised endocytic zones of neuronal dendrites and spines (Blanpied et al., 2002). However, even at these hot spots of endocytosis, clathrin assembly occurs with an average time constant of 19 seconds, which is slower than in the parasite. This suggests unique features of coated vesicle formation, one of which may be the absence of the adaptor complex AP-2 that is the second major structural protein of coated pits in mammalian cells (Morgan et al., 2002b).
Endocytosis may be important for removing anti-VSG antibodies from the cell surface (Russo et al., 1993; O'Beirne et al., 1998); that is, up to a certain antibody level in the blood, the parasites may be able to evade Fc-receptor-mediated phagocytosis by macrophages. In fact, quantification in vitro of the rate of antibody endocytosis/degradation shows remarkably rapid kinetics of anti-VSG-IgG endocytosis (M.E., unpublished). Therefore, the high rate of endocytosis may contribute to the persistence of T. brucei in the vascular system of mammals.
Pathway of VSG through the endocytic system
The information on the trafficking of VSG and of fluid-phase cargo through the endocytic system of T. brucei is summarised schematically in Fig. 5 (compare also Fig. 4D). We would like to argue that the fraction (66%) of the clathrin-containing compartment that receives VSG within 10 seconds after the start of endocytosis (Fig. 3A) corresponds to class I CCVs. These vesicles move towards the region of the lysosome, where they deliver VSG and fluid-phase marker to essentially all RAB5-positive early endosomes (Fig. 2A and Fig. 3B). Therefore, we propose that early endosomes are an obligatory station on the intracellular path of VSG. Kinetic experiments based on electron microscopy have confirmed that VSGbiotin and the fluid-phase marker HRP become rapidly associated with circular profiles of EC (C.G.G., unpublished).
An interpretation of the VSG pathway between the early endosomes and the RAB11-positive exocytic carriers, which eventually deliver VSG back to the flagellar pocket membrane, is less straightforward. Approximately 2 seconds and 6 seconds after its first appearance in the RAB5-positive compartment, VSG becomes associated with 58% of the RAB7- and 53% of the RAB11-positive compartments, respectively, with similar half lives (Fig. 3C,D). The same half life is also compatible with the rate at which a fraction of the VSG separates from the fluid-phase marker (Fig. 3E), suggesting that all three of these half lives describe different aspects of the same process. In contrast to VSG, the fluid-phase marker has access to the entire RAB7-positive compartment (data not shown). Therefore, part of the VSG appears to move directly from early endosomes to recycling endosomes in a first stage of sorting and recycling, whereas the remainder moves on to late endosomes. This is then followed by a second and slower phase of VSG recycling from the late endosomes to recycling endosomes, which appears to occur concomitantly with the separation between VSG and content marker because both processes occur with half lives, T1/2=47-50 seconds. The fluid-phase marker could subsequently be delivered from late endosomes to the lysosome.
We have previously shown that VSG is depleted in the class II CCVs that bud from EC, suggesting that in this way VSG is concentrated in the cisternae by negative selection. Accordingly, class II CCVs are also depleted of endocytosed VSGbiotin (C.G.G., unpublished). Importantly, these vesicles have now turned out to be strongly positive for ferritin or HRP (Fig. 4G-I). In mammalian cells, similar endosome-derived CCVs have generally been considered to be directed towards the plasma membrane (Stoorvogel et al., 1996; Futter et al., 1998) (see also Sönnichsen et al., 2000). Instead, we would like to propose that at least for the T. brucei system they carry cargo to late endosomes or directly to the lysosome or both. As judged by either fluorescence or by electron microscopic evidence, neither the lysosome nor the Golgi complex are stations in the recycling pathway of VSG. Similarly, cell surface-derived glycoproteins on endosomes of macrophages are efficiently recycled at two pre-lysosomal stages (Thilo et al., 1995) without reaching the lysosomal membrane (Haylett and Thilo, 1986).
In mammalian cells, GPI-anchored proteins have been shown to enter via clathrin-independent pathways and are routed thereafter to a special GPI-anchored-protein-enriched endosomal compartment (GEEC), to late or recycling endosomes or to the Golgi complex (Skretting et al., 1999; Nichols et al., 2001; Sabharanjak et al., 2002; Fivaz et al., 2002). Their intracellular trafficking appears to depend on the cell type as well as on the specific GPI-anchored protein under investigation, and, at several stations, the importance of cholesterol- and sphingolipid-rich domains have been implicated in their sorting (see Sharma et al., 2002). The endocytic recycling pathway for the GPI-anchored VSG in trypanosomes is comparatively straightforward: entry and exit at the flagellar pocket are defined; no special intracellular compartments have to be invoked, and sorting appears to occur by negative selection in endosomes.
The present study poses several questions that should be addressed in the future. First, how is the endo- and exocytic traffic spatially regulated in the flagellar pocket? Is its membrane functionally uniform or is it divided in sub-regions, which either support clathrin-mediated endocytosis or fusion of exocytic carriers? Second, although the membrane area of disk-shaped exocytic carriers is comparable to that of the class I CCVs, their luminal volume is much smaller. Therefore, if 90% of the fluid-phase marker is recycled, it must either be concentrated in the exocytic carriers or there exists an unknown recycling route. Third, the relationship of the RAB5- and the RAB11-positive cisternae can be analysed in more detail. As discussed for mammalian cells, these compartments may rapidly communicate by fusion/fission events or even be continuous (Sönnichsen et al., 2000). Therefore, although the molecular description of the endocytic pathway in trypanosomes at this stage is still rudimentary when compared with that of mammalian cells or yeast, the advantages of the parasite system merit further investigations.
We thank Mark Field (London) and Jay Bangs (Madison) for their generous supply of antibodies. We are grateful to Mark Carrington (Cambridge, UK) and Paul Webster (New Haven) for helpful discussions. M.E. and M.B. acknowledge the support of the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft, P.O. thanks the Fond der Chemischen Industrie for its support.