Studying macrophage biology in the context of a whole living organism provides unique possibilities to understand the contribution of this extremely dynamic cell subset in the reaction to infections, and has revealed the relevance of cellular and molecular processes that are fundamental to the cell-mediated innate immune response. In particular, various recently established zebrafish infectious disease models are contributing substantially to our understanding of the mechanisms by which different pathogens interact with macrophages and evade host innate immunity. Transgenic zebrafish lines with fluorescently labeled macrophages and other leukocyte populations enable non-invasive imaging at the optically transparent early life stages. Furthermore, there is a continuously expanding availability of vital reporters for subcellular compartments and for probing activation of immune defense mechanisms. These are powerful tools to visualize the activity of phagocytic cells in real time and shed light on the intriguing paradoxical roles of these cells in both limiting infection and supporting the dissemination of intracellular pathogens. This Review will discuss how several bacterial and fungal infection models in zebrafish embryos have led to new insights into the dynamic molecular and cellular mechanisms at play when pathogens encounter host macrophages. We also describe how these insights are inspiring novel therapeutic strategies for infectious disease treatment.
The immune system has evolved through the constant interplay between microbes and their multicellular hosts. Selective forces acting on both sides have driven the evolution of a wide variety of virulence mechanisms in pathogens and alternative control mechanisms in their hosts. In vivo modeling of infectious disease is essential for understanding this complexity and translating it into novel therapeutic interventions. The immune system, innate and adaptive, is well-conserved among vertebrates. The zebrafish (Danio rerio) offers an optically and genetically accessible vertebrate model to study host-pathogen interactions (Renshaw and Trede, 2012; van der Vaart et al., 2012; Ramakrishnan, 2013). At the embryonic and early larval stages, zebrafish provide the opportunity of studying the relevance of innate immunity in a context where no adaptive response has yet been developed, given that early lymphocytes make their first appearance in 4-day-old larvae and a full adaptive immunity requires several weeks to be mounted (Lam et al., 2004; Page et al., 2013).
Macrophages and neutrophils are the main phagocytic cell types of the innate immune system. Zebrafish models provide unique tools for studying the function of phagocytic cells, and these studies can effectively complement studies in other infectious disease models. Other recent reviews highlighted the use of zebrafish for understanding neutrophil biology (Henry et al., 2013; Shelef et al., 2013). Here, we will discuss six zebrafish models for important human pathogens (Mycobacterium, Salmonella, Burkholderia, Staphylococcus, Shigella and Candida), emphasizing the novel insights that these models have recently provided into macrophage biology and highlighting how this could lead to the finding of new host-derived therapeutic strategies.
Zebrafish macrophage biology and tools for investigating macrophage function
Ontogeny and properties of early macrophages in zebrafish
The first macrophage precursors appear in the zebrafish embryo as early as 20 hours post-fertilization (hpf) from the anterior lateral plate mesoderm (Herbomel et al., 1999). Following migration to the yolk sac, they differentiate and either invade the head mesenchyme, where they will later differentiate into microglial cells (the resident macrophages of the brain), or enter the blood circulation (Herbomel et al., 1999; Herbomel et al., 2001). These cells, named primitive macrophages, retain proliferative capability and have been reported to exist in mammals too (Takahashi et al., 1996; Herbomel et al., 1999). They can remove apoptotic cells, are able to sense and respond to invading microbes, and can eradicate non-pathogenic infections. Primitive macrophages readily phagocytose microbes from the blood circulation or when present in tissues. In contrast, neutrophils (which develop slightly later) are less efficient in phagocytosing microbes in the blood, but are potent scavengers of surface-associated bacteria (Colucci-Guyon et al., 2011).
Primitive macrophages are gradually replaced by different lineages of macrophages deriving from definitive hematopoiesis, the process that will produce specialized pluripotent cells with the ability to differentiate into all types of mature blood cells. The first wave of definitive hematopoiesis starts at 24 hpf in the posterior blood island or caudal hematopoietic tissue (CHT) with the differentiation of erythromyeloid progenitors (Bertrand et al., 2007). By 48 hpf, these pluripotent progenitors are replaced with another subset of hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells (HSPCs), now able to also differentiate into the lymphoid lineage. These cells originate from the AGM (aorta, gonads and mesonephros), derived from the lateral posterior mesoderm. After leaving the AGM, they migrate to and nest in the CHT, and will provide the second wave of definitive hematopoiesis (Murayama et al., 2006; Bertrand et al., 2007). Development of HSPCs and their emergence from aortic endothelium is remarkably conserved between zebrafish and mammals (Bertrand et al., 2010; Kissa and Herbomel, 2010; Boisset et al., 2010).
Following the second wave of hematopoiesis, macrophage precursors are released into the circulation and will extravasate to seed tissues throughout the whole body, where they differentiate into tissue macrophages. Starting from 4 days post-fertilization (dpf), the kidney marrow, which is the main hematopoietic tissue of the adult fish, develops and will progressively replace the embryonic hematopoietic system. Another component of the mononuclear phagocyte system is represented by the dendritic cell (DC) population, which is also present in zebrafish larvae and can be detected from 8–12 dpf (Wittamer et al., 2011; Svahn et al., 2013).
The infection studies discussed below, using zebrafish embryo and larval models, do not distinguish macrophages from circulating monocytes. Furthermore, possible functional differences between macrophages from primitive or definitive hematopoietic origins are generally not addressed. For more detailed and comparative descriptions of the processes of hematopoiesis in zebrafish and mammals we refer to other reviews (Stachura and Traver, 2011; Jagannathan-Bogdan and Zon, 2013).
Macrophage defense mechanisms and subversion by intracellular pathogens
Macrophages sense the presence of infection through microbial-specific molecules and host-derived inflammatory mediators. Their chemoattraction to the site of infection depends largely on the function of G-protein-coupled receptors (Xu et al., 1996; Cotton and Claing, 2009). Scavenger and complement receptors play a major role in phagocytosis (Elomaa et al., 1995), and Toll-like receptors (TLRs), in cooperation with other pattern-recognition receptors (PRRs), initiate the innate immune response (O’Neill et al., 2013). TLRs, found on the cell surface and membranes of vesicular compartments, recognize pathogen- and damage-associated molecular patterns (PAMPs and DAMPs, respectively). Another main class of PRRs, the NOD-like receptors (NLRs), performs the same function in the cytosol (Bertin et al., 1999; Inohara et al., 1999). Some NLRs participate in the assembly of the inflammasome, a multiprotein complex able to activate the caspase-1 cascade, which triggers processing of pro-inflammatory cytokines, such as IL1B (interleukin 1 beta), and full activation of the innate immune response (Martinon et al., 2002).
When engulfed by macrophages, microorganisms are exposed to a number of defense mechanisms within the resulting phagosome and through its subsequent fusion with lysosomes. These include the production of reactive oxygen and nitrogen species (ROS and RNS, respectively) (Minakami and Sumimotoa, 2006; El-Gayar et al., 2003), exposure to antimicrobials, the activity of proteases, and acidification (Schmidtchen et al., 2002; Park et al., 1996; Vandal et al., 2008). Escape from the phagosome triggers septin caging and antibacterial autophagy as additional defense mechanisms (Mostowy et al., 2010; Deretic et al., 2013).
Intracellular pathogens have evolved many strategies to counteract these defenses. These counter-strategies are mediated by virulence factors, which are often secreted directly into the host cell via specialized secretion systems such as the T3SS (type III secretion system) of Gram-negative pathogens and the T7SS (type VII secretion system) of pathogenic mycobacteria (Abdallah et al., 2007; Baxt et al., 2013). Pathogens can also induce significant reprogramming of their host cells through manipulation of signaling pathways and chromatin remodeling; however, these mechanisms are still poorly understood (Masaki et al., 2013; Wang et al., 2005). Intracellular pathogens often block phagosome maturation and fusion with lysosomes or manipulate the vesicular system such that the phagosome is modified to resemble the endoplasmic reticulum or a Golgi-like compartment (Duclos and Desjardins, 2000). Furthermore, several pathogens inject virulence factors that promote actin polymerization to actively stimulate their uptake by both non-phagocytic and phagocytic cells (Ogawa et al., 2008). Pathogens that are able to escape from the phagosome have mechanisms to evade autophagy and can spread from the initially infected cell to other cells by acquiring actin-based motility (Ogawa et al., 2005; Ogawa et al., 2008). Other virulence mechanisms can induce inflammation and different cell-death programs to facilitate the dissemination of infection (Hilbi et al., 1998). These different virulence strategies are schematically depicted in Fig. 1.
Macrophage markers and transgenic lines
The development of transgenic zebrafish lines with fluorescently labeled leukocytes (supplementary material Table S1) has been key to the successful application of zebrafish for immunological studies. However, until recently, the lack of a specific reporter for the macrophage lineage limited the study of this myeloid subset. This has now been remedied with the development of the csf1ra and mpeg1 reporter lines (Gray et al., 2011; Ellett et al., 2011). These genes are robust markers for macrophages at embryonic and larval stages, because they are co-expressed with the pan-leukocytic marker lcp1 but not with the neutrophil markers mpx and lyz (Meijer et al., 2008; Zakrzewska et al., 2010). Despite the fact that csf1ra is macrophage-specific within the immune cell types, it is also expressed in neural crest cells and derivatives, such as the xanthophores. Nevertheless, the highly motile macrophages can be distinguished easily from the immobile xanthophores in time-course experiments (Gray et al., 2011). Reporter lines using the mpeg1 promoter label macrophages but not xanthophores (Fig. 2A; supplementary material Movie 1) and, combined with a neutrophil marker, can show the different kinetics of macrophage and neutrophil responses to infection and wounding, as well as the dynamic interactions between the two cell types (Ellett et al., 2011). The mpeg1 reporter also labels microglia and it has been suggested to label other antigen-presenting cells, such as the Langerhans dendritic cells, but these could not be detected before 8–9 dpf (Svahn et al., 2013).
Expression of the Gal4 transcription factor under the control of macrophage or neutrophil promoters in combination with a UAS-nitroreductase-mCherry line allows for the specific ablation of one of the two phagocyte populations. This approach can be used to investigate their individual contributions to the immune response and infectious disease pathogenesis (Gray et al., 2011; Prajsnar et al., 2012). Alternatively, spi1/pu.1 antisense morpholino knockdown can be used to block the development of either macrophages exclusively or of both macrophages and neutrophils, depending on the concentration used (Su et al., 2007). Similarly, irf8 tools have also been used to deplete specific myeloid cell populations and to skew the development of their progenitors towards macrophages or neutrophils. Morpholino knockdown of irf8 can completely deplete macrophage differentiation while stimulating an increased output of neutrophils, and irf8 overexpression can direct myeloid development towards macrophage differentiation (Li et al., 2011).
Many other transgenic lines that label either the entire myeloid population, the early myeloid subset, microglia or all antigen-presenting cells are also very useful for the study of macrophage biology (supplementary material Table S1).
In vivo visualization of macrophage function
Visualization of live macrophage behavior in zebrafish embryos can be achieved with great structural detail using digitally enhanced differential interference contrast (DIC) microscopy (Herbomel et al., 1999; Davis et al., 2002; Herbomel and Levraud, 2005; Davis and Ramakrishnan, 2009). More recently, there has been tremendous progress in the use of transgenic marker lines (supplementary material Table S1) and labeled pathogens that facilitate live imaging in spatial and temporal dimensions (Fig. 2; supplementary material Movies 2, 3). Photoconvertable fluorescent proteins such as Kaede and Dendra2 have been exploited to show that cells from the CHT can be recruited distally to infection foci and wounds (Yoo et al., 2011), and that mycobacterium-infected macrophages egress from primary granulomas to initiate secondary infection foci (Davis and Ramakrishnan, 2009). For imaging of phagocyte migration, pathogens or specific chemoattractants can be injected subcutaneously or into body cavities such as the otic vesicle and hindbrain ventricle, which can be reached without generating extensive tissue damage, thereby preventing wound-induced leukocyte mobilization (Colucci-Guyon et al., 2011; Benard et al., 2012; Sarris et al., 2012; Yang et al., 2012; Deng et al., 2013; Cambier et al., 2014). To visualize phagocytosis and the intracellular fate of bacteria, the pHrodo dye can be conjugated to bioparticles or to live or heat-killed bacteria (Fig. 2D), providing constitutive fluorescence in one channel and additional fluorescence in another channel following exposure to an acidic environment (Hall et al., 2009). Furthermore, the nature of the compartments where the pathogens reside can be investigated with combinations of different vital stains, most of which are permeable into zebrafish embryos when added to the water. Several pH-sensitive dyes (LysoSensor and LysoTracker) do not distinguish between lysosome-dependent or -independent phagosome acidification mechanisms, but they can be used simultaneously with methods for detection of the activity of lysosomal proteases (MagicRed-Cathepsin and DQ-BSA) (Peri and Nüsslein-Volhard, 2008). Different methods allow in situ detection of ROS and RNS responses during infection in zebrafish embryos (Hall et al., 2012; Hall et al., 2013; Bilan et al., 2013; Elks et al., 2013). Also, tools for visualizing ATP, calcium effluxes and apoptosis have been efficiently used in zebrafish (Peri and Nüsslein-Volhard, 2008; Cheung et al., 2011; Sieger et al., 2012). Furthermore, an increasing number of transgenic marker lines for vesicular compartments are becoming available that will help in elucidating the subcellular locations where pathogens reside in vivo (supplementary material Table S2).
New insights into macrophage-pathogen interactions
M. marinum is a natural pathogen of zebrafish that causes granulomatous necrotic lesion formation in host tissues. These lesions are histologically very similar to those generated by Mycobacterium tuberculosis, the etiological agent of human tuberculosis (Prouty et al., 2003; Swaim et al., 2006). In adult zebrafish, M. marinum can cause a latent infection and the bacteria can be reactivated from dormancy by immunosuppressive treatment, as is the case for M. tuberculosis, which is estimated to have infected one third of the world population (Parikka et al., 2012; Gengenbacher and Kaufmann, 2012). Tuberculosis therapy is limited by a number of problems, including the poor response of dormant mycobacteria to antibiotics, the increasing prevalence of multidrug-resistant strains and the lack of an effective vaccine against latent or reactivated tuberculosis (Ottenhoff and Kaufmann, 2012). The lack of a mouse model for tuberculosis that fully recapitulates the disease and the risk of working with the human pathogen owing to its airborne transmission emphasize the need for alternative models. The unique accessibility of the early stages of granuloma formation in zebrafish larvae has made the zebrafish-M. marinum host-pathogen pair one of the most productive models used to unravel the core pathogenic processes of mycobacterial infections (Davis et al., 2002; Ramakrishnan, 2013; Cronan and Tobin, 2014) (Fig. 3A). Notably, the use of this model has already provided several direct translational applications for human disease treatments (Table 1).
Infection of zebrafish embryos with M. marinum has demonstrated that macrophages are sufficient to initiate granuloma formation in the absence of adaptive immunity (Davis et al., 2002). Subsequently, this model changed the widespread view of granulomas, historically regarded solely as host-protective structures, by showing that early granulomas promote mycobacterial dissemination (Fig. 3A) and that their formation is driven by virulence determinants of the RD1 locus, encoding ESX1, a secretion system conserved in all pathogenic mycobacteria (Volkman et al., 2004; Abdallah et al., 2007; Davis and Ramakrishnan, 2009; Ramakrishnan, 2013). Furthermore, the ESX-1-secreted protein ESAT-6 (Early secreted antigenic target 6) was found to induce matrix metalloproteinase Mmp9 production by epithelial cells surrounding the infection focus, which in turn facilitates macrophage infiltration. As a result, the application of Mmp9 antagonists has been suggested as a host-directed anti-tuberculosis therapy (Volkman et al., 2010) (Table 1). The notion that granulomas are dynamic structures, even during latent infection, is supported by a study of M. tuberculosis infection in the macaque model (Lin et al., 2009).
Mycobacteria are well known for developing drug tolerance. The zebrafish embryo model has demonstrated that their intramacrophage localization correlates with development of resistance and that granulomas promote dissemination of this resistant population. Upregulation of bacterial efflux pumps, which are required for intracellular growth, can mediate drug tolerance both in M. marinum-infected zebrafish and in M. tuberculosis-infected human macrophages. Efflux-pump inhibitors, already available on the market, can reduce this tolerance, and their addition to standard anti-tuberculosis therapy might therefore shorten treatment duration (Adams et al., 2011; Adams et al., 2014) (Table 1).
Another important insight into tuberculosis pathogenesis concerns the relevance of the inflammatory status. A zebrafish mutagenesis screen revealed Lta4h (Leukotriene A4 hydrolase) as a host factor that strongly correlates with M. marinum susceptibility (Tobin et al., 2010). This enzyme is required for producing LTB4 (Leukotriene B4), a powerful proinflammatory chemoattractant. Lta4h deficiency correlates with a less inflamed status, due to redirection of its substrates to anti-inflammatory lipoxins, resulting in reduced levels of proinflammatory cytokines such as tumor necrosis factor (TNF). The crucial role of TNF in controlling mycobacterial infection is exemplified by the increased risk of tuberculosis in patients with chronic inflammatory disorders treated with TNF antagonists (Wallis, 2008). However, excessive production of TNF is also associated with higher susceptibility to tuberculosis. This has been shown in zebrafish and other animal models as well as in tuberculosis meningitis patients, where a polymorphism at the LTA4H locus that causes increased TNF production has been linked with more progressive disease symptoms (Tsenova et al., 1999; Tobin et al., 2010). Hyper-inflamed and hypo-inflamed statuses have both been associated with necrotic death of infected macrophages and consequent extracellular release of the pathogen (Clay et al., 2008; Roca and Ramakrishnan, 2013). In conditions of low inflammation, macrophages passively undergo necrotic death because they are unable to control intracellular bacterial growth, whereas, in conditions of high inflammation, macrophages actively initiate two ROS-mediated necroptotic pathways, dependent on the activation of the mitochondrial permeability transition pore complex (mPTPC) and of the lysosomal acid sphingomyelinase (aSMase). Drugs targeting these pathways prevent activation of the necroptotic program in the zebrafish model (Roca and Ramakrishnan, 2013). The crucial role of the inflammatory status emphasizes the importance of designing personalized patient therapies: patients with the proinflammatory LTA4H genotype might benefit from classical anti-inflammatory drugs [such as corticosteroids or non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs)]; however, these drugs should be avoided in patients with the opposite genotype (Tobin et al., 2010; Tobin et al., 2012). Drugs that directly block the ROS-linked necroptotic pathways will benefit the proinflammatory genotypes without generating detrimental effects on the other genotypes, because the necroptotic pathways are exclusively triggered in hyper-inflamed conditions (Roca and Ramakrishnan, 2013) (Table 1).
The inflammatory response is initiated by TLR recognition of PAMPs. Myd88, a central adaptor in TLR signaling, was recently shown to be required for control of systemic M. marinum infection in zebrafish embryos (van der Vaart et al., 2013). In contrast, the initial recruitment of macrophages to a localized M. marinum infection in the hindbrain was found to be largely Myd88 independent (Cambier et al., 2014). This effect was linked to the presence of PDIM (phthiocerol dimycoceroserate) lipid on the surface of pathogenic mycobacteria, which masks the underlying PAMPs. Non-pathogenic mycobacteria, which lack PDIM, induce a robust immune response and are efficiently contained. Mutation of the PDIM transporter (ΔmmpL7) and of a factor involved in PDIM synthesis (Δmas) can restore Myd88-dependent macrophage recruitment and allow an efficient intracellular RNS response against invading bacteria. Interestingly, in the absence of a TLR response, macrophages can still be recruited. This Myd88-independent recruitment was found to be mediated by cell-surface phenolic glycolipids (PGLs), which induce macrophage recruitment through a pathway that is analogous to the mammalian CCL2-CCR2 (CC-motif chemokine ligand–receptor 2) axis. The macrophages recruited in this situation are suggested to be more permissive to intracellular bacterial growth, because they do not drive the strong intracellular RNS response. These observations might also explain why M. tuberculosis establishes infection in the lower rather than in the higher respiratory tracts, because the latter is exposed to resident and environmental microbes that can make macrophages more competent for intracellular killing via a continuous transduction of TLR-dependent immune signaling (Cambier et al., 2014).
Although macrophages are the main cell type infected by M. marinum following intravenous injection, neutrophils are also important for early infection control in zebrafish. In the early granuloma, the protective role of neutrophils was found to depend on ROS production (Yang et al., 2012). Prior to granuloma formation, neutrophils, both infected and non-infected, also produce RNS (Elks et al., 2013). This RNS production is dependent on inducible nitric oxide synthase (iNOS) and can be modulated by genetic or pharmacological modulation of Hif-α (Hypoxia inducible factor alpha) transcription factors. Increasing Hif-1α signaling or decreasing Hif-2α signaling primes neutrophils with higher levels of RNS prior to infection, thereby limiting susceptibility to mycobacterial infection. Increasing host RNS output by therapeutic targeting of the Hif-α pathway might shift the balance in favor of the host and can thereby be explored as a strategy to complement antibiotic interventions (Table 1).
In addition to the classical microbicidal mechanisms of macrophages, antibacterial autophagy has emerged as an important supplementary control mechanism in mycobacterial infections (Deretic et al., 2013). Using the zebrafish model, colocalization of mycobacteria with the autophagic marker Lc3 has been demonstrated in vivo (van der Vaart et al., 2012). Moreover, actintail formation and recruitment of septin cages have been visualized, the latter also being associated with Lc3 and autophagy (Mostowy et al., 2013). The induction of dram1 (DNA damage-regulated autophagy modulator 1) during infection suggests an immunological function of this autophagy modulator, and the zebrafish model could be further exploited to investigate therapeutic targeting of selective autophagy pathways (Mostowy et al., 2013; Meijer et al., 2014).
Very recently, a zebrafish larval model has also been established to study a rapidly growing mycobacterium, Mycobacterium abscessus, an emerging pathogen that causes severe pulmonary infections in individuals with cystic fibrosis (Bernut et al., 2014). The study showed that the virulent rough morphotype of M. abscessus is transported to the central nervous system by macrophages, where bacteria released from dying cells form massive amounts of serpentine cords that grow too large to be phagocytosed, leading to acute and lethal infection. Furthermore, M. tuberculosis can also be disseminated by zebrafish larval macrophages and is sensitive to antibiotic treatment in this model (Carvalho et al., 2011). It will be of interest to investigate novel therapeutic strategies emerging from the study of M. marinum (Table 1) also in the zebrafish models for these human pathogens.
Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium (S. typhimurium)
Like many other Gram-negative enterobacteria, Salmonella can infect a diverse range of hosts and cause zoonotic diseases (Fàbrega and Vila, 2013). The S. enterica serovar Typhimurium, often referred to as S. typhimurium, represents a common agent of enteric fever, gastroenteritis and bacteremia, often linked to food poisoning. Although the bacterium is not a natural fish pathogen, zebrafish embryos are strongly susceptible to S. typhimurium in experimental settings. Pathogenesis in fish involves some of the acute symptoms seen in humans, including bacteremia and a strong proinflammatory host response (‘cytokine storm’), which are associated with early lethality of the zebrafish embryos (van der Sar et al., 2003; Stockhammer et al., 2009). The life cycle of S. typhimurium has been well characterized in infected cell cultures and in mammalian systems: the pathogen is able to alternate phases of intracellular replication within phagocytes and extracellular growth within the damaged tissue (Dunlap et al., 1992; Salcedo et al., 2001). Similar observations have been made in the zebrafish embryo model. S. typhimurium, like M. marinum, can survive intracellularly in macrophages of zebrafish embryos (Fig. 3B), but infected cells do not disseminate into tissues. Instead, following intravenous injection, the infection remains restricted to the vasculature, with bacteria multiplying both in macrophages and extracellularly at the epithelium of blood vessels (van der Sar et al., 2003). Although infection with wild-type bacteria causes early lethality, bacteria with mutations in lipopolysaccharide (LPS) are attenuated in macrophages and are more sensitive to extracellular lysis, likely due to complement factors (van der Sar et al., 2003).
In sharp contrast with M. marinum infection, S. typhimurium infection leads to a cytokine storm within hours after intravenous injection (Stockhammer et al., 2009; Ordas et al., 2011; van der Vaart et al., 2012). At the transcriptional level, this response is similar to that observed in infection with the natural fish pathogen Edwardsiella tarda (van der Vaart et al., 2013). This proinflammatory transcriptional response provides a useful readout for characterizing the consequences of mutation or knockdown of host genes involved in the immune response. Deficiencies in the TLR signaling components Myd88 and Traf6 strongly reduce expression of transcriptional regulators, signaling components and effectors of the immune response (Stockhammer et al., 2010; van der Vaart et al., 2013). Conversely, these gene groups are hyper-induced following knockdown of the protein tyrosine phosphatase Shp1 (also known as Ptpn6) (Kanwal et al., 2013). These observations are consistent with the function of these genes in mammalian animal models and human patients, where MYD88 and TRAF6 mutations are associated with immunodeficiencies and SHP1 mutations cause inflammatory phenotypes and autoimmune defects. Control of S. typhimurium and other infections in zebrafish is impaired both under conditions of a reduced or hyper-induced immune response, indicating the importance of highly balanced regulatory mechanisms (van der Vaart et al., 2013; Kanwal et al., 2013). Micro-RNAs (miRNAs), including members of the miR-146 family, have been implicated in fine-tuning of the mammalian innate immune response and, in zebrafish embryos, miR-146 is induced by S. typhimurium in a Myd88-Traf6-dependent manner. Although no major effects on known targets of the Myd88-Traf6 pathway were observed, apolipoprotein-mediated lipid transport emerged as a newly identified infection-inducible pathway under control of this miRNA family (Ordas et al., 2013).
The signals involved in recruitment of phagocytes to local infection remain to be elucidated. Chemokines, such as Cxcl8 (Il8) and the orphan ligand Cxcl-c1c, are highly induced rapidly upon S. typhimurium infection (Stockhammer et al., 2009). Using other bacterial infection models, the function of the CXCL8-CXCR2 signaling axis in neutrophil recruitment has been shown to be conserved in zebrafish (Sarris et al., 2012; Deng et al., 2013). Local S. typhimurium infection has also been shown to induce the recruitment of macrophages via the chemokine receptor Cxcr3.2, one of the zebrafish orthologs of human CXCR3 (Zakrzewska et al., 2010). The ligand association of Cxcr3.2 remains to be established.
In addition to phagocyte recruitment, localized infection also triggers emergency-driven hematopoiesis (Hall et al., 2012). Early neutropenia is a frequent outcome of S. typhimurium hindbrain infection in zebrafish embryos, and this is compensated for by increased granulopoiesis. The activity of iNOS (and thus the production of the pleiotropic mediator nitric oxide), was found to be necessary to stimulate the expansion and proliferation of HSPCs in response to infection-dependent neutropenia. The induction of iNOS is dependent on expression of the transcription factor C/ebpβ (CCAAT enhancer-binding protein β) in HSPCs. This is suggested to be an effect of elevated circulating levels of Gcsf (Granulocyte colony stimulating factor), produced by activated macrophages at the infection site (Hall et al., 2012).
The S. typhimurium infection model has recently led to new insight into the connection between infection control and host cell metabolic modulation (Hall et al., 2013). Profound adaptations in glucose and lipid metabolism occur within infected immune cells. For example, in response to stimulation by Salmonella pathogenic factors, macrophages increase their uptake of lipids to fuel ROS production (Hall et al., 2013). In line with this, S. typhimurium infection induces the expression of the mitochondria-associated enzyme Irg1 (Immunoresponsive gene 1) within infected zebrafish macrophages. This protein directs the catabolism of fatty acids to sustain mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation and in turn leads to the production of mitochondrial ROS, contributing to intracellular degradation of phagocytosed bacteria. Irg1 holds promise as a new therapeutic target at the interface of inflammation and metabolism (Hall et al., 2013) (Table 1).
The B. cepacia complex (Bcc) is represented by several closely related Gram-negative species that are able to survive freely in the environment or replicate within different hosts, including amoebae, invertebrates, vertebrates and plants (Mahenthiralingam et al., 2008). In humans, opportunistic infection by Bcc frequently occurs in cystic fibrosis or immunocompromised individuals and represents a recurrent cause of fatal complications (Saiman and Siegel, 2004). The capability to survive and infect a wide range of hosts suggests that Bcc species are highly adaptable to different niches and produce multiple virulence factors; however, the complex mechanisms of host-pathogen interactions underlying infections with B. cenocepacia and other Bcc strains remain largely unknown. In particular, it has been difficult to establish conclusively whether B. cenocepacia can survive intracellularly. Visualizing infection in zebrafish embryos helped to answer this key question, by demonstrating the ability of this pathogen to survive within macrophages (Fig. 3C). Following the creation of an intramacrophage replication niche, the bacterial infection disseminates by non-lytic expulsion from infected cells, induces immune cell aggregations and ultimately causes fatal systemic bacteremia (Vergunst et al., 2010).
The zebrafish model system has also provided a valuable contribution to the investigation of the in vivo relevance of several B. cenocepacia virulence factors. A quorum-sensing-deficient cepR strain was shown to be strongly attenuated, indicated by a reduced ability to replicate intracellularly and to disseminate efficiently from infected macrophages. Furthermore, differences in virulence were observed between strains from a panel of clinical isolates (Vergunst et al., 2010). Loss of the third replicon, pC3 (a non-essential megaplasmid associated with several virulence determinants), results in highly attenuated infection in multiple hosts, including zebrafish embryos (Agnoli et al., 2012; Agnoli et al., 2014). Mutants in pC3 are not able to grow significantly in vivo, but are not eradicated, suggesting that the pC3-linked virulence factors are dispensable for intramacrophage survival (Agnoli et al., 2012). A function in adaptation to a wide range of environments, rather than a direct role in modulating intracellular growth, might explain the prevalence of the pC3 replicon among Bcc isolates (Agnoli et al., 2014).
Together, these studies demonstrate the usefulness of the zebrafish model for analysis of B. cenocepacia mechanisms of intracellular survival and virulence.
S. aureus is the causative agent of a wide range of infectious pathologies such as sty, pneumonia, endocarditis, osteomyelitis and septicemia (Lowy, 1998), which remain important causes of morbidity and of complications in hospitalized patients. Although not a natural pathogen of zebrafish, both embryos (Prajsnar et al., 2008) and adults (Lin et al., 2007) exhibit clear acute symptoms when infected with this Gram-positive pathogen, providing a useful model for bacteremia (Fig. 3D).
S. aureus has long been considered an extracellular pathogen, but there is accumulating evidence that it can also survive and replicate in phagocytes (Rigby and DeLeo, 2012). The zebrafish embryo model has contributed significantly to our understanding of the nature and relevance of the intracellular phase in the life cycle of this pathogen (Prajsnar et al., 2008; Prajsnar et al., 2012). Live imaging showed that, upon intravenous infection, S. aureus is completely phagocytosed by macrophages and neutrophils (Prajsnar et al., 2008; Li and Hu, 2012). Although some embryos clear the infection in a phagocyte-dependent manner, other embryos develop overwhelming infection, indicating that the bacteria can subvert the phagocyte-killing mechanisms (Prajsnar et al., 2012).
When larvae are co-infected with two isogenic, but differently labeled, S. aureus clones, the infection evolves by forming focal lesions that are predominantly monoclonal and, during the course of overwhelming infection, the ratio between the original strains is often skewed towards one predominating strain (Prajsnar et al., 2012). This phenomenon is fully dependent on phagocyte activity. These data suggest that most of the phagocytes are able to clear the infection but a population of phagocytes provides an intracellular protective niche in which some bacteria gain the ability to replicate and resist, to ultimately be released and disseminate. Consistent with this, co-infection in a murine sepsis model resulted in kidney abscesses that contained predominantly one strain of S. aureus and thus were likely founded by single bacteria (Holtfreter et al., 2013). The relevance of this work for clinical treatments is underscored by a recent study showing that the use of sub-curative antibiotic doses can support the preferential expansion of antibiotic-resistant bacteria during a mixed infection (McVicker et al., 2014). Selective ablation of macrophages or neutrophils in the zebrafish model has revealed that neutrophils are most likely to form the privileged niche responsible for disseminated infection of S. aureus (Prajsnar et al., 2012). Interesting remaining questions include elucidation of the mechanisms by which some bacteria from the initial inoculum are able to avoid being killed by neutrophils, and determination of whether S. aureus can also resist macrophages in vivo, as suggested by human cell culture studies (Kubica et al., 2008).
S. flexneri, a human-adapted Escherichia coli species, is a causative agent of diarrhea and dysentery in humans, generally deriving from orofecal contaminations. Like other enterobacteria, it mostly affects the digestive tract; however, in advanced infectious stages, it can lead to bacteremia and systemic sepsis. In the early phase of infection, the pathogen can interact with membranes of host cells, inject virulence determinants, and induce ruffling and internalization (Ogawa et al., 2008). In this actively induced ingestion mechanism resides its capability to establish intracellular infection in non-phagocytic cells, such as epithelial cells associated with the digestive tract. Once it is internalized, it can escape from phagosomes and survive freely in the cytosol. Subsequently, the pathogen can spread through intestinal epithelial cells by actin-based motility (Fig. 3E). Microfold cells allow Shigella to transverse the intestinal epithelium, where they encounter macrophages. Death of infected macrophages and subsequent destabilization of the epithelium due to inflammation allows more Shigella to infiltrate the tissue and invade epithelial cells through the basal membrane. Survival and replication in macrophages, eventually followed by macrophage pyroptosis, is fundamental to allowing dissemination and extensive colonization of the intestinal epithelium (Ashida et al., 2011).
Recently, a zebrafish model for S. flexneri was established, and this has been used to show that intravenously administrated bacteria can survive and replicate both in macrophages and in non-immune cells (Mostowy et al., 2013). The pathogenicity of Shigella is highly dependent on the presence of T3SS virulence factors, and avirulent strains can be successfully combated by the zebrafish innate immune system and are not able to induce phagocytosis in non-phagocytic cells. Live imaging shows that replication of S. flexneri in macrophages ultimately induces cell death, whereas bacteria are more efficiently contained and degraded within neutrophils. Neutrophils also act as scavengers, eliminating infected dead cells. Macrophages are not able to retain the infection within vacuoles and bacteria spread into the cytosol, where they can colocalize with actin and septin cages (Fig. 3E).
In mammalian cultured cells, cytosolic S. flexneri can be targeted for autophagy via both ubiquitin-dependent and -independent pathways, and, as a counteractive mechanism, the bacteria can secrete virulence factors to escape autophagy (Ogawa et al., 2005; Mostowy et al., 2011). Colocalization with the autophagy marker Lc3 followed by electron microscopic analysis in the zebrafish model confirmed that autophagy targeting is associated with entrapment of S. flexneri in septin cage-like structures (Mostowy et al., 2010; Mostowy et al., 2013). Reduction of autophagy, via knockdown of the autophagy-related receptor p62, increases the infection burden of zebrafish larvae and this effect is specific only for the T3SS-positive strain that is able to escape into the cytosol (Mostowy et al., 2013). These data support the hypothesis that antibacterial protection provided by efficient autophagic machinery is essential to properly counteract S. flexneri infection. The ability to monitor S. flexneri infection in a transparent zebrafish host provides new possibilities to assess the relevance of autophagy in vivo in immune and non-immune cells, and to develop new strategies for anti-bacterial therapies targeting this process (Table 1).
C. albicans is an opportunistic dimorphic fungus that grows in yeast and hyphal forms (Gow et al., 2011). Most of the human population carries C. albicans as a harmless constituent of the epidermal, mucosal and intestinal flora. However, uncontrolled systemic candidiasis and fungal growth on the mucosal surfaces can cause severe and life-threatening infectious complications, particularly in immunocompromised individuals. In zebrafish embryos, as in humans, C. albicans can be phagocytosed by both neutrophils and macrophages (Chao et al., 2010; Brothers et al., 2011). Live observations reveal that, in a non-compromised zebrafish host, this intracellular localization leads to a transitory standoff phase in which the yeast form survives and replicates, but does not germinate or lyse the host cell (Fig. 3F). Subsequently, the fungi switch to the more virulent hyphal form and proliferate exuberantly in individuals that fail to contain the infection, whereas they revert to the yeast form in most surviving embryos (Brothers et al., 2011). Intracellular yeast forms are unable to undergo the yeast-to-hyphal transition, even under conditions of impaired oxidative-stress response, in contrast with previous in vitro data in which filamentous growth was observed within cultured macrophages (Brothers et al., 2013). Therefore, macrophages apparently have an enhanced ability to control infection in the in vivo environment.
Although germination was shown to be independent of the phagocyte-specific NADPH oxidase (PHOX), this enzyme was found to be essential to produce an efficient oxidative-stress response against C. albicans and to control filamentous growth (Brothers et al., 2011; Brothers et al., 2013). Previously, the limitation of fungal growth was ascribed mainly to direct fungal destruction by ROS; however, imaging in zebrafish revealed a non-canonical role for PHOX and for the epithelial dual NADPH oxidase (DUOX) in recruitment of phagocytes to C. albicans infection sites. Therefore, impaired phagocyte recruitment to invading Candida under conditions of NADPH oxidase deficiency seems to be the cause of the overall reduction in containment of the infection and, consequently, of massive extracellular hyphal growth. Although localized infection with wild-type C. albicans is unable to induce chemoattraction under conditions of NADPH oxidase deficiency, infection with a yeast-locked mutant strain (edt1Δ/Δ) can be efficiently counteracted by phagocyte recruitment and internalization, even in pan-NADPH-oxidase-depleted conditions. This suggests that the hyphal transition (or another edt1-associated program) is also able to attenuate ROS-independent phagocyte recruitment, thus explaining the relevance of host ROS-driven chemoattraction mechanisms to counteract C. albicans infection (Brothers et al., 2013).
The study of intracellular pathogens in zebrafish macrophages has led to new mechanistic insights that are inspiring novel host-directed therapeutic strategies (Table 1). The real-time imaging possibilities in zebrafish will also be very useful for elucidating the mechanisms underlying macrophage migration processes, as has already been demonstrated by the study of neutrophils in the larval system (Sarris et al., 2012; Henry et al., 2013; Shelef et al., 2013). A question that is very relevant both for infectious diseases and for cancer biology concerns the presence of different pro- and anti-inflammatory macrophage subtypes in zebrafish. Classically activated (M1) and alternatively activated (M2) macrophages, resembling the phenotypes of mammalian macrophages, have been identified in different fish species (Forlenza et al., 2011). That different macrophage subtypes might already be present in early zebrafish larvae has been suggested, but this remains to be further investigated (Feng et al., 2010). The early larval stages, which are optimally suited for imaging and for genetic and pharmacological interventions, can give much information on the intracellular survival mechanisms of pathogens, as demonstrated by the studies discussed herein. The early larval stages are also very useful for studying the response of microglia to brain injuries or infection, contributing to a deeper understanding of the role of these specialized macrophages in neurodegenerative diseases (Sieger et al., 2012; Sieger and Peri, 2013). Studying the antigen-presentation function of macrophages and DCs at later developmental stages is becoming increasingly feasible owing to advances in technologies for generating stable mutant lines (Clark et al., 2011; Blackburn et al., 2013; Kettleborough et al., 2013). Dynamic interactions between macrophages and neutrophils that are emerging from recent studies in zebrafish are of considerable interest for further study (Ellett et al., 2011; Yang et al., 2012; Elks et al., 2013). The use of the zebrafish model has already provided insights into the in vivo relevance of intracellular defense mechanisms such as ROS and RNS production and autophagy. We expect that further use of this powerful model will continue to make important contributions towards the understanding of innate immunity and of the virulence strategies that pathogens use to subvert innate host defenses.
The authors thank Georges Lutfalla (University of Montpellier II) and Graham J. Lieschke (Monash University) for the kind gift of the Tg(mpeg1:mCherry-F) and Tg(mpeg1:Gal4-VP16/UAS-E1b:Kaede) lines, respectively. These lines were used to make Fig. 2 and the movies.
This article is part of a Special Issue, Spotlight on Zebrafish: Translational Impact. See all the articles in the issue at http://dmm.biologists.org/content/7/7.toc.
V.T. is a Marie Curie fellow in the Initial Training Network FishForPharma (PITN-GA-2011-289209) funded by the 7th Framework Programme of the European Commission. S.M. is supported by a fellowship from the Higher Education Commission of Pakistan. Work that led to this Review was additionally supported by the European 7th framework project ZF-Health (FP7-Health-2009-242048), by the Smart Mix Program (NWOA_6QY9BM) of The Netherlands Ministry of Economic Affairs and The Netherlands Ministry of Education, Culture and Science, and by the Leiden University Fund (LUF).
The authors declare no competing financial interests.